The W. A. Franke College of Business
Virtual Visit Request info Apply
MENUMENU
  • Academics
    • Undergraduate »
      • HRM Program
      • Accounting Program
      • Economics Program
      • Finance Program
      • Information Systems
      • Management Program
      • Marketing Program
      • Interdisciplinary Global Programs
    • Graduate »
      • MBA
      • Master of Business Administration in Healthcare
    • Certificates »
      • Business Analytics - Undergraduate
      • Financial Planning - Undergraduate
      • Non-Profit & Social Entrepreneurship - Undergraduate
      • Risk Management and Insurance - Undergraduate
      • Business Foundations - Graduate
  • About
    • News
    • Events
    • Business Outreach »
      • Economic Policy Institute
      • NAU Nonprofit Center
      • National Advisory Board
      • Accounting Advisory Council
      • Information Systems Advisory Council
      • HRM National Advisory Board
    • Our Namesake
    • Faculty & Staff Directory
    • FCB By the Numbers
    • Building Facts & Figures
    • Accreditation
  • Schools & Departments
    • School of Hotel & Restaurant Management
  • The Franke Experience
    • The Franke Experience Overview
    • Clubs & Organizations
    • Experiential Learning
    • Professional Development »
      • Career Development Office
      • Business Communication Center
      • Professional Selling Program
      • Business Leadership Program
      • Professionalism Recognition Program
      • Risk Management and Insurance Program
    • Veteran Student Center
    • Faculty Research
    • Visits with Warren Buffett
  • Recruiters & Companies
    • Recruiters & Companies Overview
    • Hiring
    • Recruiting Events
    • Partnership Opportunities »
      • Offer an Executive Job Shadow
      • Corporate Career Panel Participation
      • Professional Selling Program Partnerships
  • Alumni
    • Alumni Overview
    • Stay Connected
    • Get Involved
    • Give
    • Hall Of Fame »
      • Biographies
      • Criteria
  • Resources
    • Resources Overview
    • FCB Ambassadors
    • Office of Advising & Academic Support
    • Pathways to Professional Leadership »
      • Suitable
      • FAQs
    • Scholarships
    • For Faculty »
      • Information Technology & Help Desk
    • Support Services
  • NAU
  • The W. A. Franke College of Business
  • WPS 14-01

Working Paper Series

Mincer-Zarnovitz Quantile and Expectile Regressions for Forecast Evaluations under Asymmetric Loss Functions

Posted January 2014

Authors

Kemal Guler
Pin T. Ng
Zhijie Xiao

Abstract

Forecast is pervasive in all areas of applications in business and daily life and, hence, evaluating the accuracy of a forecast is important for both the generators and consumers of forecasts. There are two aspects in forecast evaluation: (1) measuring the accuracy of past forecasts using some summary statistics and (2) testing the optimality properties of the forecasts through some diagnostic tests. On measuring the accuracy of a past forecast, we illustrate that the summary statistics used should match the loss function that was used to generate the forecasts. If there is strong evidence that an asymmetric loss function has been used in the generation of a forecast, then a summary statistic that corresponds to that asymmetric loss function should be used in assessing the accuracy of the forecast instead of the popular RMSE or MAE. On testing the optimality of the forecasts, we demonstrate how the quantile regressions and expectile regressions set in the prediction-realization framework of Mincer and Zarnowitz (1969) can be used to recover the unknown parameter that controls the potentially asymmetric loss function used in generating the past forecasts. Finally, we apply the prediction-realization framework to the Federal Reserve’s economic growth forecast and forecast sharing in a PC manufacturing supply chain. We find that the Federal Reserves values over prediction approximately 1.5 times more costly than under prediction. We also find that the PC manufacturer weighs positive forecast errors (under forecasts) about four times as costly as negative forecast errors (over forecasts).

Download full working paper (PDF).

The W. A. Franke College of Business
Location
Building 81
W. A. Franke College Of Business
101 E. McConnell Drive
Flagstaff, Arizona 86011-5066
Mailing Address
PO Box 15066
Flagstaff, Arizona 86011-5066
Email
fcb@nau.edu
Phone
928-523-3657
Fax
928-523-7331
Social Media
Visit us on Twitter Facebook Instagram LinkedIn